news Breaking News
clock
News

Double tax agreements: What they do, and what they don’t – and why the difference matters

  • Sarah Simson
  • Nov 04, 2026
  • 2 views
Double tax agreements: What they do, and what they don’t – and why the difference matters
Double tax agreements can help prevent the same income from being taxed twice, but their protection is not automatic and depends on the domestic tax rules of each country.
MENU  DATA  SIGN IN SUBSCRIBE   Create account Free   Newsletters Free   Insider Gold R70pm   Insider Pro Advisors   Support journalism PODCASTS LISTEN     MoneywebNOW   Moneyweb@Midday   RSG Geldsake   SAfm Market Update   All podcasts Click an ADVISOR   Advisor profiles   Advisor views   Reader questions   Submit a question   Sign up MOBILE Tools: Daily indicators Sens Comparison Tool Watchlist   Unit Trusts: Click a Unit Trust Unit Trust stats Unit Trust holdings ETFs & ETNs Asset Managers ALL DATA TOOLS Shares: Click a Company Company stats Winners & losers 52-week highs/lows Top by value/volume Top 40 Companies Consensus forecasts JSE sectors Business calendar Director dealings Dividend watch Dividend History Company contacts Annual Reports Heatmap JSE Indices Value Move % World Indices Value 1 day 7 day Currencies Value Move % Commodities Value Move % 5 SHARES Facebook Twitter LinkedIn WhatsApp Email Print Share this article × 5 Shares Facebook Twitter LinkedIn WhatsApp Email Print Double tax agreements: What they do, and what they don’t – and why the difference matters Join our free mailing list for top business news. × Next article Stable metros, skilled visas and US trade deal would give business reason to invest × Soapbox   Double tax agreements: What they do, and what they don’t – and why the difference matters Double tax agreements can help prevent the same income from being taxed twice, but their protection is not automatic and depends on the domestic tax rules of each country. By Sarah Simson · 4 Nov 2026, 04:00  South African foreign tax credits are generally capped at the local tax attributable to the same income, meaning excess foreign tax paid may not be recovered. Image: AdobeStock Double tax agreements (DTAs) are often misunderstood. People with cross-border investments, income or business interests may assume that a treaty – an agreement between two countries that stipulates how taxing rights will be allocated – between South Africa and another country automatically protects them from being taxed twice. In reality, a DTA is not a complete tax code, and relying on it without understanding the underlying domestic tax rules can lead to unexpected costs. Understanding what these agreements cover – and where their protection ends – is essential to effective cross-border tax planning. Read: Sars tightens scrutiny of double tax agreement non-resident claims Domestic tax law comes first A DTA does not create a tax liability. That is determined by the domestic legislation of the relevant country. A country may tax an individual because they are resident or semi-resident there, because income arises from a source within its borders, or because a business operates there through a permanent establishment. In South Africa, the Income Tax Act 58 of 1962 generally taxes residents on their worldwide income and non-residents on income from a South African source. A DTA becomes relevant when domestic law establishes a potential tax liability. Its purpose is to regulate the countries’ respective taxing rights and provide relief where applicable. It can restrict or reduce tax that domestic law would otherwise impose, but it cannot create a liability where none exists. Starting with the treaty before establishing the position under domestic law is therefore a common mistake. Not all treaties are the same South Africa has separate DTAs with individual countries. Although many draw on the OECD Model Tax Convention, and some on the United Nations Model, each reflects the terms negotiated between the two countries. Definitions, withholding tax rates, residence rules, permanent establishment tests and relief mechanisms can differ significantly. A provision that protects a taxpayer under one treaty may be absent or more restrictive under another. Read: Oppenheimer leads a complex lifestyle, but where is he resident? Treaties can also change. They may be amended, replaced or terminated, while multilateral initiatives such as the OECD’s Multilateral Instrument can modify how existing agreements operate. ADVERTISEMENT CONTINUE READING BELOW Anyone relying on a DTA for tax planning should therefore confirm that they are consulting the applicable version, including relevant amendments and effective dates. Advice based on outdated provisions can have costly consequences. Check which taxes the treaty covers Another important consideration is the type of tax involved. DTAs generally address specified taxes on income, and capital gains tax falls within the South African income tax system. However, an income tax treaty should not automatically be assumed to cover estate duty or inheritance taxes. South Africa has concluded only a limited number of agreements dealing with taxes on estates. Someone with assets in more than one country who assumes an income tax treaty will prevent double taxation on death could therefore be exposed to an unexpected liability. The relevant tax must be identified first, followed by confirmation that the applicable treaty covers it. Read: Protection of tax bases in the OECD spotlight Relief does not always eliminate double taxation South Africa’s extensive treaty network helps mitigate double taxation, but relief does not necessarily eliminate every additional tax cost. Where South Africa grants a credit for foreign tax paid, that credit is generally limited to the South African tax attributable to the same income. If the foreign tax is higher, the excess may not be recoverable. Consider a South African resident who earns foreign income of R1 million and pays R400 000 in foreign tax. If the South African tax attributable to that income is R270 000, the South African credit is capped at R270 000. No South African tax would remain payable on that income, but the additional R130 000 in foreign tax would not be recovered through the credit. The result is a real tax cost that may not have been anticipated. A treaty can provide valuable relief without delivering the tax-neutral outcome a taxpayer expected. ADVERTISEMENT: CONTINUE READING BELOW Relief may be available without a treaty The absence of a DTA does not necessarily mean that double taxation cannot be mitigated. South African domestic law provides for unilateral relief in certain circumstances. Section 6quat of the Income Tax Act allows qualifying foreign tax credits for certain foreign taxes paid on foreign-source income included in South African taxable income, subject to prescribed conditions and limitations. Read: Demystifying double taxation agreements: What expats need to know Tax relief options can help South African expats protect their foreign-earned income In some circumstances, a deduction may also be available. The Estate Duty Act 45 of 1955 provides a measure of relief for certain foreign death duties on qualifying foreign assets. These provisions have their own requirements and limitations, but they can be important where South Africa has no relevant treaty with the other country or where a treaty does not cover the tax concerned. A practical approach to cross-border tax The starting point for any cross-border tax assessment should be to establish the liability under each country’s domestic law. The next steps are to identify the correct and current treaty, establish whether it covers the tax in question, apply its allocation and relief provisions, and consider whether domestic law offers additional relief. For individuals and businesses with international interests, the distinction matters. A DTA is a framework for coordinating taxing rights, not a blanket guarantee against double taxation. Understanding its scope and limitations before making financial or estate-planning decisions can help avoid costly surprises. Sarah Simson, is a consultant attorney at Thomson Wilks. Google See more of Moneyweb Google News Follow our coverage Newsletters Get news in your inbox Social Media Join the conversation Social media Follow us on our official channels: TAGS: cross-border investments |  Double Tax Agreement |  Income Tax Act |  tax liability COMMENTS   0 You must be signed in to comment. SIGN IN SUBSCRIBE or create a free account. Free users can leave 4 comments per month. Subscribers can leave unlimited comments via our website and app. MORE Soapbox Stable metros, skilled visas and US trade deal would give business reason to invest 9 Nov 2026 / Busi Mavuso Agoa exit: A setback, not a supply chain crisis 8 Nov 2026 / Ernest van Biljon The biodiversity review that matters most will happen in the credit committee 7 Nov 2026 / Brigitte Burnett Investing in an ODD world 5 Nov 2026 / Izak Odendaal SA’s Agoa exit is not the end of US market access 3 Nov 2026 / Wandile Sihlobo Your medical scheme is absorbing your pay increase 3 Nov 2026 / Francois Stofberg LATEST INDICATORS   USD / ZARGBP / ZAREUR / ZARBTC / USDJSE ALSIGOLDBrent Crude $ More Indicators   ADVISOR VIEWS Why cash can be one of the most valuable investments in retirement 9 Nov 2026 / Wouter Fourie Giving well requires more than good intentions 9 Nov 2026 / Sherry Tapfuma The retirement maths that catches even experienced investors by surprise 6 Nov 2026 / Wouter Fourie Life is unpredictable, don’t procrastinate 6 Nov 2026 / Marius Fenwick The first 90 days after losing a spouse: Are we preparing the person left behind? 5 Nov 2026 / Carina van Rooyen Go to Click an Advisor   Editor's Picks Commented Top Read 1Rubio considers leaving Trump administration2Eskom faces R4bn curtailment bill as solar power surges3Sun International quietly shuts down Kimberley casino 1Most ‘extreme value’ on the JSE in decades – top fund manager   102Millionaire magnet: Cape Town faces shortage of luxury homes   83Local government elections: Results for SA’s eight metros   8 1 Michael Lewis ousted as TFG chair 2 Eskom faces R4bn curtailment bill as solar power surges 3 Most ‘extreme value’ on the JSE in decades – top fund manager ADVISOR VIEWS Why cash can be one of the most valuable investments in retirement 9 Nov 2026 / Wouter Fourie Giving well requires more than good intentions 9 Nov 2026 / Sherry Tapfuma The retirement maths that catches even experienced investors by surprise 6 Nov 2026 / Wouter Fourie Life is unpredictable, don’t procrastinate 6 Nov 2026 / Marius Fenwick Go to Click an Advisor   Moneyweb Newsletters * indicates required Email Address * First Name * Last Name Moneyweb newsletters Moneyweb NOW - Morning news Moneyweb Weekly Wrap-up Op RSG Geldsake vanaand (in Afr) On SAFM Market update tonight Moneyweb Events and Webinars Moneyweb Crypto By subscribing, you agree to receive the Moneyweb emails you selected above. You can unsubscribe at any time. View our privacy policy. MORE Soapbox Stable metros, skilled visas and US trade deal would give business reason to invest 9 Nov 2026 / Busi Mavuso Agoa exit: A setback, not a supply chain crisis 8 Nov 2026 / Ernest van Biljon The biodiversity review that matters most will happen in the credit committee 7 Nov 2026 / Brigitte Burnett Investing in an ODD world 5 Nov 2026 / Izak Odendaal SA’s Agoa exit is not the end of US market access 3 Nov 2026 / Wandile Sihlobo Your medical scheme is absorbing your pay increase 3 Nov 2026 / Francois Stofberg LATEST ARTICLES Moneyweb@Midday Petrol relief in sight as oil prices fall and the rand strengthens 9 Nov 2026 / Jeremy Maggs   ActionSA weighs its next move as election results set the stage for coalition talks. The growing gap between SA’s rich and cash-strapped consumers. And why Africa is struggling to sell more goods to the world. Shoprite teams up with Investec to take on SA’s banks Podcast brought to you by STANLIB Asset Management Visa’s unprecedented growth story LATEST OPINION Stable metros, skilled visas and US trade deal would give business reason to invest Off the Radar Which market gains the most from a collapse in oil? Agoa exit: A setback, not a supply chain crisis SPONSORED Aangebied deur Kruger Internasionaal Kenners antwoord luisteraarsvrae 6 November 2026 Gareth Collier Firecrest Group (Pty) Ltd ASK AN ADVISOR Is my TFSA and RA portfolio positioned correctly for long-term growth? 20 October 2026 Home In depth Bonitas Discovery Invest Eduvos Fedgroup Future Forex GIBS Hollard Liberty Merchant West Nedbank Agri Nedbank CIB Ninety One OUTsurance Peregrine Capital Platinum Portfolios PSG Wealth Standard Bank Group Stanlib Investing Commodities Equities ESG ETFs Offshore investing Property SME Unit Trusts News South Africa Africa International Budget Companies and Deals Economy Fast News Investigations Industry Markets Marketingweb Mineweb Tech Radio – Listen Live SAFM Market Update RSG Geldsake Podcasts Be a Better Investor The Ballot Sheet The Business of Africa Crypto podcasts Doen jou eie ding How to Make Money Moneyweb@Midday MoneywebNOW Mzansi Business The Property Pod Special Report MyMoney Financial Planning Personal Finance Tax Opinion Columnists Soapbox Tools and data 52-Week Highs/Lows Annual Reports Asset Managers Business Calendar Company Stats Company contact info Comparison Tool Click a Company Consensus forecasts Daily Indicators Directors’ Dealings Dividend History ETFs & ETNs Heatmap JSE Sectors Portfolios/Watchlist Sens Top 40 Companies Top by Value & volume Unit Trust Holdings Unit Trust Stats Unit Trust Search Winners & Losers Moneyweb Crypto Crypto podcasts Bitcoin Ethereum MoneywebTV Executive Exchange Webinars All videos Click an Advisor Advisor Profiles Advisor Views Reader questions Submit a question Sign up – Click an Advisor Enquire – Click an Advisor Subscribe Insider GOLD Insider PRO – Click an Advisor Newsletters Support journalism Moneyweb App Stay updated Login Register Information & FAQ Help About us Contact us Advertise Authors & Presenters Careers Investor relations PAIA Manual Terms of Use (Privacy Policy, Ts & Cs) Cookie Policy Complaints Home News Newsletters Insider subscription Daily indicators Click a company Click an Advisor Radio / Livestream Podcasts About Moneyweb Advertise with us Contact Moneyweb Help Information & FAQ Moneyweb App Privacy Policy / Terms of Use Price and trade data source: JSE Ltd. Statistics calculated by Profile Data. Data is delayed by at least 15 minutes. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use. Copyright © 2026 Moneyweb (Pty) Ltd. All Rights Reserved. ',"none"!==article_obj.is_sponsor&&(output+=''+article_obj.is_sponsor+""),output+=''+anchorTag,output+='',output+=''+article_obj.date+"",output+="",output+=""}function movePanel(id){jQuery("#"+id+"-mobile").html(jQuery("#"+id).html())}function hideMobilePanel(id){jQuery("#"+id).css("display","block"),jQuery("#"+id+"-mobile").css("display","none")}function showMobilePanel(id){jQuery("#"+id).css("display","none"),jQuery("#"+id+"-mobile").css("display","block")}function completedWindowResizing(){var width=jQuery(window).width();width Home News Latest News Fast News South Africa Africa AI Budget Companies and Deals Covid-19 Economy Eskom Industry International Investigations Markets Marketingweb Mineweb Tech In depth Bonitas Discovery Invest Eduvos Eris Property Group Fedgroup Future Forex GIBS Hollard Jetour Liberty LookSee Merchant West Ninety One Old Mutual Group Communications Otto1890 OUTsurance Peregrine Capital PSG Wealth Standard Bank Group Stanlib Webinars Events View all MyMoney Educational Video Series Financial Planning Personal Finance Retirement #SavingsMonth Tax Investing Commodities Equities ESG ETFs Offshore investing Property SME Unit Trusts Crypto Crypto news Crypto podcasts Bitcoin Ethereum Opinion Columnists Soapbox Desk of the President Podcasts All podcasts Be a Better Investor The Ballot Sheet with Ray Mahlaka The Business of Africa Crypto podcasts Executive Exchange FixSA How to Make Money With … Mandates & Megaphones Moneyweb@Midday MoneywebNOW Mzansi Business The Property Pod Supernatural Stocks Special Report Doen jou eie ding Small Business Conversations Radio Listen live RSG Geldsake SAFM Market Update MoneywebTV Executive Exchange Mzansi Business Click an Advisor Sign up for Click an Advisor All advisor profiles Advisor views Reader questions Submit your question Contact us Tools and data All data tools 52-week highs/lows Asset Managers Annual Reports Business calendar Click a Company Company contacts Company stats Comparison Tool Daily indicators Directors’ dealings Dividend History ETF & ETN search Heatmap JSE sectors Portfolio Tool / Watchlist SENS Top 40 Companies Top by value/volume Unit Trust holdings Unit Trust Search Unit Trust Stats Winners and losers INSIDER SUBSCRIPTION APP NEWSLETTERS PODCASTS RADIO / LISTEN LIVE VIDEOS WEBINARS TRENDING FOLLOW US: SEARCH: Search Search JSE companies: Unit Trusts ETFs/ETNs SENS TRENDING: More TNPA invests R375m in Richards Bay port road upgrades 8 Nov 2026  /  Terri-ann Brouwers   Local government elections: Results for SA’s eight metros 8 Nov 2026  /  Jarryd Westerdale, The Citizen   8 IN DEPTH: Sponsored Brought to you by Val de Vie Sales of Val de Vie Vivante Village South about to launch Brought to you by Peregrine Capital Two centuries in the baking: Inside Premier FMCG’s rebuild SIGN IN: Email Password Stay logged in Forgot password Create a free account, or contact us to assist. Access all our articles Post comments and replies News & Sens email alerts Premium data tools Sens archive and Sens PDFs. SUBSCRIBE NOW You can cancel at any time.

Please Accept Cookies for Better Performance