news Breaking News
clock

Judge Hartle’s exchange with court employee detailed at tribunal

Hartle faces allegations of gross misconduct over claims of derogatory language.

Judge Hartle’s exchange with court employee detailed at tribunal

The Judicial Conduct Tribunal hearing of Judge Belinda Hartle of the Eastern Cape Division of the High Court has heard details of an exchange between the Eastern Cape High Court Judge and court employee, Thozamile Semekazi. Hartle is facing allegations of gross misconduct over claims that she used racist and derogatory language towards Semekazi in May last year. Hartle had previously apologised to Semekazi for using a swear word and acknowledged that her conduct was unprofessional. However, she denies ever using racist language, saying she had expressed frustration over the late delivery of court files, which had allegedly left her with insufficient time to prepare for court proceedings. Tribunal evidence leader Advocate Benny Kalakgosi read out a WhatsApp exchange between the two at the time of the incident. “It says, ‘Hello Mr Semekazi. I realise that I used a swear word in giving meaning to my frustration just now. But it was not intentional and certainly not directed at you personally. I apologise if it offended you. Kind regards, Belinda…It is the first time in my 23 years of working in this department that I have been sworn at by someone in your position. You degraded me in front of your secretary and belittled me, which is so humiliating and hurtful and so despondent. And I didn’t answer. Even your expression and your outrage towards me were so unprofessional and sad.” Today’s court proceedings in the stream below: 

 

Read the full article at SABC News

Article details
Published
November 10, 2026
Last updated
November 15, 2026
Written by
ADM Staff
Category
Politics
Reading time
2 min read
Views
14
A
Written by

ADM Staff

Platform administrator at Afridev Monitor. Oversees the newsroom platform, user access and publishing settings, keeping the site reliable and editorially consistent. Afridev Monitor tracks development, policy and business news across Africa.

Leave a Reply

Cancel Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Please Accept Cookies for Better Performance