MENU DATA SIGN IN SUBSCRIBE Create account Free Newsletters Free Insider Gold R70pm Insider Pro Advisors Support journalism PODCASTS LISTEN MoneywebNOW Moneyweb@Midday RSG Geldsake SAfm Market Update All podcasts Click an ADVISOR Advisor profiles Advisor views Reader questions Submit a question Sign up MOBILE Tools: Daily indicators Sens Comparison Tool Watchlist Unit Trusts: Click a Unit Trust Unit Trust stats Unit Trust holdings ETFs & ETNs Asset Managers ALL DATA TOOLS Shares: Click a Company Company stats Winners & losers 52-week highs/lows Top by value/volume Top 40 Companies Consensus forecasts JSE sectors Business calendar Director dealings Dividend watch Dividend History Company contacts Annual Reports Heatmap JSE Indices Value Move % World Indices Value 1 day 7 day Currencies Value Move % Commodities Value Move % SHARES Facebook Twitter LinkedIn WhatsApp Email Print Share this article × Shares Facebook Twitter LinkedIn WhatsApp Email Print Nobel laureate Navi Pillay talks justice, power and accountability Join our free mailing list for top business news. × Next article Vehicle repossession: What banks can and cannot legally do × Moneyweb@Midday Nobel laureate Navi Pillay talks justice, power and accountability Despite the scale of the challenges, her message is clear: we must not surrender to despair. Jeremy Maggs · 26 Oct 2026, 12:54 You can also listen to this podcast on iono.fm here. JEREMY MAGGS: She has spent a lifetime confronting injustice, from the brutality of apartheid to the horrors of genocide and war crimes. Judge Navi Pillay has served as a judge at the International Criminal Court (ICC), as United Nations (UN) High Commissioner for Human Rights, and as a leading voice for accountability across the world. Now recognised with the Nobel Peace Prize, she joins us at a time when international law is under extraordinary pressure and the world’s most powerful nations increasingly appear willing to ignore it. Read: South African human rights lawyer Navi Pillay awarded Nobel peace prize Navi Pillay’s Nobel peace prize is a vote of confidence in a global legal order under fire Judge Pillay, thank you very much. Let me start with this, you’ve devoted your entire professional life to fighting injustice. Does the Nobel Peace Prize feel like a victory to you, or just a reminder, perhaps, of how much remains undone? NAVI PILLAY: Well, Jeremy, obviously, I didn’t apply for the award. I didn’t realise they were even considering me. I met with the selection board members in The Hague two days ago, and they appeared to have been researching me from January – a whole year – and I didn’t know. So firstly, I do celebrate this award. But secondly, you are quite right: it’s a reminder of unfinished work and as old as I am, I’ve been saying I’m not going to stop doing human rights work as long as the violations continue. It is a particularly troubling moment for human rights, but especially for the rule of law, for multilateralism, where states get together and make decisions in the organs that have the power, the Security Council, the General Assembly on, for instance, whether to attack another country. All that’s a threat, but from my point of view, it’s a threat to international justice. That troubles me most as the threatened sanctions against the ICC and thereafter that the Trump administration followed through. Where in the world would you have a government sanctioning or taking action against judges for the orders they deliver? So it’s very alarming, and it’s a deeply emotional matter. If I may continue, Jeremy, the first thing I did when I left Nuremberg and got to The Hague was to go to that court. I was invited by the president to come join them at their full staff meeting. If you see that, how much that visit alone meant to the staff and how much their emotions and fears of the threat hanging over them was conveyed to me just on their faces. I went there to show solidarity, to deliver hope that the international community, the entire population of the world, ordinary people, they want justice and accountability. We will never let the ICC be destroyed. JEREMY MAGGS: You talk about never giving up hope and have just outlined how you’ve helped build the international system of justice. How worried are you at this point, at this juncture? The very system that you’ve devoted your life to is now starting to unravel, it would seem. NAVI PILLAY: Yes, yes, I and many, many others are worried because the threats are real, and [those making them] can deliver on those threats. They have remote-controlled armed drones. You can be killed in your home without even being aware that you are targeted for killing. Families are at risk, children are at risk. It’s just reckless killing of civilians. That’s unusual. Of course, we’ve always had conflicts, since World War II, there [have been] conflicts in various parts of the world, but we have never had a third world war. In fact, Europe, a few years ago, was given the Nobel Prize for Peace simply because [it had] prevented war in Europe since World War II. ADVERTISEMENT CONTINUE READING BELOW So therefore, the threat we now face is real. It’s being done by leaders in the United States, leaders in Israel, who are defying the international rule of law. JEREMY MAGGS: Is the suggestion that it’s now a fundamental breakdown of international law? NAVI PILLAY: I would still call it a threat because of what I saw at the court and the resilience that both the judges, the prosecuting team and the hundreds of staff who were there. They believe there should be no impunity for these serious crimes, and they will continue to work. Because of that resistance and resilience, combined with civil society, with people, my support comes from ordinary people all over the world. I gave a number of interviews in The Hague, even three to Japanese television [stations]. So these calls for interviews are coming from very many countries. I’m surprised that they’re all following this. They’ve explained to me that that arises from these concerns about the breakdown of the international rule of order. JEREMY MAGGS: Judge Pillay, in that respect, then, and you talk about the voices and the concerns of ordinary people. Does it still give you a degree of hope that ordinary people are bringing about the notion that things can still turn around? NAVI PILLAY: Yes, I do. Maybe because of my experience as the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights for six years and going to various countries, seeing both the highest level of government as well as people on the ground and just being informed. I concluded that it’s not a trajectory going right down to the ground, even from top to down. Some people actually said it’s the end of human rights. This was during the first term served by President Trump, and many students at American universities asked me to address them. I was told they’re all very depressed. Read/listen: Navi Pillay’s Nobel: A victory for justice, a headache for Trump I said to them, I thought it was ups and downs, that’s what happens in human rights protection, ups and downs, because people will never let go of these hard-earned mechanisms to make governments accountable. JEREMY MAGGS: Do you think international law is genuinely international at this point, or does it still apply more forcefully to weaker countries than more powerful ones? NAVI PILLAY: We don’t have a perfect system at all, Jeremy. We will have what one can call a universal permanent world court if all the states sign up to the Rome Statute, and they haven’t. Big countries, in fact, three of the veto-holding states – Russia, China and the United States – are not parties to this court. There are just 125, plus-minus, member countries that have signed up. So we still do not have a perfect system to ensure that serious violations and to ensure that atrocity crimes are not committed against civilians. I found in my experience, it’s not all the way down, this is a dead end, no, it’s ups and downs. And why? It’s because of the effort of all the human rights defenders, ordinary people speaking out about it, writing about it. There are huge protests in streets all over for the government to deliver on their promises. JEREMY MAGGS: Do you think, Judge Pillay, it’s become more difficult to persuade ordinary people, though, to believe in a system that too many will appear to have obvious double standards? NAVI PILLAY: There’s all that. Crime still continues, [and] there are double standards. For instance, I mentioned these three powerful states. They can use the veto to protect themselves from investigation or prosecution. But let’s remind ourselves, the ICC doesn’t exercise supervening jurisdiction over national jurisdictions. So there is misinformation being spread, particularly from the US and Israel, that this is what’s happening. ADVERTISEMENT: CONTINUE READING BELOW Whereas the statute is clear, the United States could now, even now, investigate and prosecute soldiers who may have violated the laws of war and crime and committed crimes such as crimes against humanity. They have, in the past, been the one country that did prosecute its own soldiers. So if they start an investigation or prosecute, the ICC will not step in. Similarly, with every country: if you prosecute and you investigate it. So really the ICC is there to help, to be an incentive to help states. I have often said that, under apartheid, we were governed by an immoral law, which was not compatible with the Universal Charter of Human Rights that the UN adopted, and which our own apartheid government supported at the UN. Yet we had no access to justice in an independent international forum, and I always felt that loss. I wished there was a better moral system than ours. But now, Jeremy, I am citing the end of apartheid as one of my grounds for hope that that there was collective action by civil society and governments all over the world, plus a change of mind from the US and the UK to support the sanctions imposed by the UN against apartheid South Africa. So that’s an example of how collective action succeeded. Therefore, we cannot lose hope. We cannot give way to pressure. We have to continue to strategise and to struggle. But it has to be without violence. We cannot condone violent protests either. JEREMY MAGGS: Judge Pillay, your award has not been without its very vocal detractors. The UN commission concluded that Israel has committed genocide in Gaza. What do you say to those who dispute that finding and question the impartiality of your investigation? NAVI PILLAY: Firstly, they have accused me and the other two commissioners – one from India and one from Australia, with the wonderful team doing all the groundwork – they have accused us of bias and of lying. The thing is, they didn’t let us into the country, but we got most of our information from inside Israel. There’s huge support there from ordinary people. We held oral hearings in Geneva. We heard from doctors and journalists. It took us two years to prepare that report. There is not a single fact that we put out there that was not personally verified by us, together with the entire machinery of the UN, that helped us with satellite footage and so on. It’s a very comprehensive work. As I said, it took us two years to prepare, and I say to our detractors that this report is written very closely to what a court judgment would look like. So we invite anybody, since the report is public, read the facts as we’ve set it out. Look at the law. Look at the statements that we set out of the utterances of leaders whom we name as responsible for genocide and make your own decision. That way, you can resist this false propaganda [that] is trying to discredit a report that will soon be considered by the highest court in the world, the ICC. JEREMY MAGGS: Judge Pillay, when governments reject those findings that you put out. What practical consequences, then, do you think should follow? NAVI PILLAY: I think there should be stronger action by other states. There should be a clear statement by other states that they support this report. Right now, there should be a clear statement from all states condemning this action taken against the ICC. All states that support the ICC, and there are 125, I think now, should strongly express their opposition and take action to ensure that the destruction of the court does not happen. So more collective action from governments and they will find the people on the streets are very ready to support them in stronger action against one or two countries trying to destroy the multilateral system, trying to destroy the international rule of law. ADVERTISEMENT: CONTINUE READING BELOW JEREMY MAGGS: What would you say directly to political leaders, Judge Pillay, who believe they are above international law? NAVI PILLAY: I would say: you passed these laws. You passed the Rome Statute. You passed the Convention Against Torture, very many treaties, the conventions on civil and political rights for everyone in the world, and the Convention on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights. Who passed these international laws? It was states. Civil society may have made demands and followed up and did lots of the drafting, but it was the decision of governments. So why don’t they deliver on the obligations that they had undertaken under these various laws? So that would be my strongest criticism. As High Commissioner, we zeroed in just on matters of concern and offered assistance and help to do that. I visited 79 countries, so it was, a great deal of work, but an objective assessment of the same problems in every country where governments fail to deliver on the demands of the people. JEREMY MAGGS: As you told me earlier, you lived through apartheid and helped shape international justice. I wonder when you look at our country today, are you proud of what you’ve become, of what we’ve become, or disappointed perhaps by the opportunities that we’ve squandered? NAVI PILLAY: I agree that we have had many opportunities. They’re not just opportunities, they are legal provisions, a wonderful Constitution that the whole world respects. But there has been no delivery on the ground and great unhappiness. We truly are deeply concerned when a major part of the population is poverty-stricken and unemployed. So great disappointment. It can be done because we do have the institutions in place. We just need proper people to ensure that they carry out their jobs properly. This is why, Jeremy, I first was surprised that I got the award because I thought I was just doing my job as the people expect me to. We need more of that, people taking responsibility for their jobs. Corruption has reached huge levels, we’re all highly disturbed about that. But I firmly believe all that can be turned around because we have what the UN calls tools to make the change, to make the transformation happen. So very good structures, very poor delivery. I can understand why we South Africans are unhappy and why we are constantly in the news for terrible crimes, especially sexual crimes against women. JEREMY MAGGS: Navi Pillay, let me ask you one final question, because I do appreciate the time you’ve given us. After everything you’ve witnessed, the cruelty, the suffering, the extraordinary courage of victims at times – have you ever come close to losing faith in humanity? NAVI PILLAY: I’m human, Jeremy, so you do have huge disappointment, your heart sinking. For instance, I still think what have I achieved as High Commissioner when the reality on the ground is that the world is so clearly divided between the very rich and powerful and the poor, and so I live troubled by that situation, the larger picture in the world. I intend to continue. I do believe Africa has suffered as a result of colonisation, and there has to be discussions on reparations, for instance. So we have much to be concerned about, but not just to sink in despair, but to take action wherever we can. This award is truly significant because they awarded it for justice and accountability. That’s how I see it. JEREMY MAGGS: Judge Navi Pillay, thank you very much for talking to me today. Google See more of Moneyweb Google News Follow our coverage Newsletters Get news in your inbox Social Media Join the conversation Social media Follow us on our official channels: TAGS: Donald Trump | El Nino | food prices | Gaza | human rights | International Criminal Court | Jeremy Maggs | Navi Pillay | Nobel peace prize | un | United Nations AUTHOR PROFILE Jeremy Maggs Follow More articles Jeremy is a media specialist with a career spanning 40 years in television, radio, and print. He is also the host of Moneyweb’s weekly FixSA podcast. COMMENTS 0 You must be signed in to comment. SIGN IN SUBSCRIBE or create a free account. Free users can leave 4 comments per month. Subscribers can leave unlimited comments via our website and app. MORE Moneyweb@Midday Vehicle repossession: What banks can and cannot legally do 23 Oct 2026 / Jeremy Maggs Who gets the vaccines? Global pandemic deal under pressure 23 Oct 2026 / Jeremy Maggs Local bus manufacturing could add billions to SA’s economy 22 Oct 2026 / Jeremy Maggs Four months in: Is SA’s new lottery operator delivering? 22 Oct 2026 / Jeremy Maggs Medicine price hike imposed without proper consultation, industry warns 21 Oct 2026 / Jeremy Maggs Who’s delivering water and who isn’t? SA’s 144 authorities mapped 21 Oct 2026 / Jeremy Maggs LATEST INDICATORS USD / ZARGBP / ZAREUR / ZARBTC / USDJSE ALSIGOLDBrent Crude $ More Indicators ADVISOR VIEWS You sold everything – now what? 26 Oct 2026 / Wouter Fourie A living annuity is a strategy, not simply a product 26 Oct 2026 / Devon Card Tax efficient transfer of family wealth: How R300 000 a year can save a South African family millions 26 Oct 2026 / Ruan Breed What is a realistic retirement withdrawal rate, and what do advice fees cost? 23 Oct 2026 / Werner Gerber How many South Africans really have R16.5m or more? 23 Oct 2026 / Hardi Swart Go to Click an Advisor Editor's Picks Commented Top Read 1Sars hands more than 100 cases linked to commissions of inquiry to the NPA2Discovery Bank CEO out-earns Group CEO for fourth year running3SAA receives R1bn guarantee, further bailouts not ruled out 1Discovery Bank CEO out-earns Group CEO for fourth year running 122SAA staggers salary payments as cash crunch deepens 113Trumpflation and other frustrations 9 1 Sars hands more than 100 cases linked to commissions of inquiry to the NPA 2 Discovery Bank CEO out-earns Group CEO for fourth year running 3 What banking in Africa will look like in five years ADVISOR VIEWS You sold everything – now what? 26 Oct 2026 / Wouter Fourie A living annuity is a strategy, not simply a product 26 Oct 2026 / Devon Card Tax efficient transfer of family wealth: How R300 000 a year can save a South African family millions 26 Oct 2026 / Ruan Breed What is a realistic retirement withdrawal rate, and what do advice fees cost? 23 Oct 2026 / Werner Gerber Go to Click an Advisor Moneyweb Newsletters * indicates required Email Address * First Name * Last Name Moneyweb newsletters Moneyweb NOW - Morning news Moneyweb Weekly Wrap-up Op RSG Geldsake vanaand (in Afr) On SAFM Market update tonight Moneyweb Events and Webinars Moneyweb Crypto By subscribing, you agree to receive the Moneyweb emails you selected above. You can unsubscribe at any time. View our privacy policy. MORE Moneyweb@Midday Vehicle repossession: What banks can and cannot legally do 23 Oct 2026 / Jeremy Maggs Who gets the vaccines? Global pandemic deal under pressure 23 Oct 2026 / Jeremy Maggs Local bus manufacturing could add billions to SA’s economy 22 Oct 2026 / Jeremy Maggs Four months in: Is SA’s new lottery operator delivering? 22 Oct 2026 / Jeremy Maggs Medicine price hike imposed without proper consultation, industry warns 21 Oct 2026 / Jeremy Maggs Who’s delivering water and who isn’t? SA’s 144 authorities mapped 21 Oct 2026 / Jeremy Maggs LATEST ARTICLES SANBS stocks fall below target ahead of festive season 26 Oct 2026 / Phenyo Selinda The blood service needs 3 500 units daily to meet patient demand. R3bn mixed-use development breaks ground in Harrismith Government fuel intervention spares motorists more pain LATEST OPINION Off the Radar Does SA have too many malls? Trumpflation and other frustrations Sars cracks down on Vat refund fraud SPONSORED Brought to you by Ninety One Infrastructure fund delivers a return of more than 10% over 12 months 23 October 2026 Schalk Louw PSG Wealth Old Oak ASK AN ADVISOR Is my TFSA and RA portfolio positioned correctly for long-term growth? 20 October 2026 Home Latest articles Fast News In depth Absa Retail and Business Banking Bonitas Eduvos Future Forex GIBS LookSee Merchant West Nedbank Agri Nedbank CIB Ninety One OUTsurance Peregrine Capital Platinum Portfolios PSG Wealth Standard Bank Group Stanlib Investing Commodities Equities ESG ETFs Offshore investing Property SME Unit Trusts News South Africa Africa International Budget Companies and Deals Economy Fast News Investigations Industry Markets Marketingweb Mineweb Tech Radio – Listen Live SAFM Market Update RSG Geldsake Podcasts Be a Better Investor The Ballot Sheet The Business of Africa Crypto podcasts Doen jou eie ding How to Make Money Moneyweb@Midday MoneywebNOW Mzansi Business The Property Pod Special Report MyMoney Financial Planning Personal Finance Tax Opinion Columnists Soapbox Tools and data 52-Week Highs/Lows Annual Reports Asset Managers Business Calendar Company Stats Company contact info Comparison Tool Click a Company Consensus forecasts Daily Indicators Directors’ Dealings Dividend History ETFs & ETNs Heatmap JSE Sectors Portfolios/Watchlist Sens Top 40 Companies Top by Value & volume Unit Trust Holdings Unit Trust Stats Unit Trust Search Winners & Losers Moneyweb Crypto Crypto podcasts Bitcoin Ethereum MoneywebTV Executive Exchange Webinars All videos Click an Advisor Advisor Profiles Advisor Views Reader questions Submit a question Sign up – Click an Advisor Enquire – Click an Advisor Subscribe Insider GOLD Insider PRO – Click an Advisor Newsletters Support journalism Moneyweb App Stay updated Login Register Information & FAQ Help About us Contact us Advertise Authors & Presenters Careers Investor relations PAIA Manual Terms of Use (Privacy Policy, Ts & Cs) Cookie Policy Complaints Home News Newsletters Insider subscription Daily indicators Click a company Click an Advisor Radio / Livestream Podcasts About Moneyweb Advertise with us Contact Moneyweb Help Information & FAQ Moneyweb App Privacy Policy / Terms of Use Price and trade data source: JSE Ltd. Statistics calculated by Profile Data. Data is delayed by at least 15 minutes. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use. Copyright © 2026 Moneyweb (Pty) Ltd. All Rights Reserved. ',"none"!==article_obj.is_sponsor&&(output+=''+article_obj.is_sponsor+""),output+=''+anchorTag,output+='',output+=''+article_obj.date+"",output+="",output+=""}function movePanel(id){jQuery("#"+id+"-mobile").html(jQuery("#"+id).html())}function hideMobilePanel(id){jQuery("#"+id).css("display","block"),jQuery("#"+id+"-mobile").css("display","none")}function showMobilePanel(id){jQuery("#"+id).css("display","none"),jQuery("#"+id+"-mobile").css("display","block")}function completedWindowResizing(){var width=jQuery(window).width();width Home News Latest News Fast News South Africa Africa AI Budget Companies and Deals Covid-19 Economy Eskom Industry International Investigations Markets Marketingweb Mineweb Tech In depth Absa Retail and Business Banking Bonitas Eduvos Future Forex GIBS LookSee Merchant West Nedbank Agri Nedbank CIB Ninety One Old Mutual Group Communications Otto1890 OUTsurance Peregrine Capital Platinum Portfolios PSG Wealth Standard Bank Group Stanlib Webinars Events View all MyMoney Educational Video Series Financial Planning Personal Finance Retirement #SavingsMonth Tax Investing Commodities Equities ESG ETFs Offshore investing Property SME Unit Trusts Crypto Crypto news Crypto podcasts Bitcoin Ethereum Opinion Columnists Soapbox Desk of the President Podcasts All podcasts Be a Better Investor The Ballot Sheet with Ray Mahlaka The Business of Africa Crypto podcasts Executive Exchange FixSA How to Make Money With … Mandates & Megaphones Moneyweb@Midday MoneywebNOW Mzansi Business The Property Pod Supernatural Stocks Special Report Doen jou eie ding Small Business Conversations Radio Listen live RSG Geldsake SAFM Market Update MoneywebTV Executive Exchange Mzansi Business Click an Advisor Sign up for Click an Advisor All advisor profiles Advisor views Reader questions Submit your question Contact us Tools and data All data tools 52-week highs/lows Asset Managers Annual Reports Business calendar Click a Company Company contacts Company stats Comparison Tool Daily indicators Directors’ dealings Dividend History ETF & ETN search Heatmap JSE sectors Portfolio Tool / Watchlist SENS Top 40 Companies Top by value/volume Unit Trust holdings Unit Trust Search Unit Trust Stats Winners and losers INSIDER SUBSCRIPTION APP NEWSLETTERS PODCASTS RADIO / LISTEN LIVE VIDEOS WEBINARS TRENDING FOLLOW US: SEARCH: Search Search JSE companies: Unit Trusts ETFs/ETNs SENS TRENDING: More Sars cracks down on Vat refund fraud 25 Oct 2026 / Richan Schwellnus 2 Learners wait seven years for R39m school 25 Oct 2026 / Nombulelo Damba-Hendrik, GroundUp IN DEPTH: Sponsored Brought to you by Eris Property Group Own in Newlands with a 10% rental guarantee and 100% finance at The Marlow Brought to you by Ninety One Infrastructure fund delivers a return of more than 10% over 12 months SIGN IN: Email Password Stay logged in Forgot password Create a free account, or contact us to assist. Access all our articles Post comments and replies News & Sens email alerts Premium data tools Sens archive and Sens PDFs. SUBSCRIBE NOW You can cancel at any time.
Nobel laureate Navi Pillay talks justice, power and accountability
Despite the scale of the challenges, her message is clear: we must not surrender to despair.
MENU DATA SIGN IN SUBSCRIBE Create account Free Newsletters Free Insider Gold R70pm Insider Pro Advisors Support journalism PODCASTS LISTEN MoneywebNOW Moneyweb@Midday RSG Geldsake SAfm Market Update All podcasts Click an ADVISOR Advisor profiles Advisor views Reader questions Submit a question Sign up MOBILE Tools: Daily indicators Sens Comparison Tool Watchlist Unit Trusts: Click a Unit Trust Unit Trust stats Unit Trust holdings ETFs & ETNs Asset Managers ALL DATA TOOLS Shares: Click a Company Company stats Winners & losers 52-week highs/lows Top by value/volume Top 40 Companies Consensus forecasts JSE sectors Business calendar Director dealings Dividend watch Dividend History Company contacts Annual Reports Heatmap JSE Indices Value Move % World Indices Value 1 day 7 day Currencies Value Move % Commodities Value Move % SHARES Facebook Twitter LinkedIn WhatsApp Email Print Share this article × Shares Facebook Twitter LinkedIn WhatsApp Email Print Nobel laureate Navi Pillay talks justice, power and accountability Join our free mailing list for top business news. × Next article Vehicle repossession: What banks can and cannot legally do × Moneyweb@Midday Nobel laureate Navi Pillay talks justice, power and accountability Despite the scale of the challenges, her message is clear: we must not surrender to despair. Jeremy Maggs · 26 Oct 2026, 12:54 You can also listen to this podcast on iono.fm here. JEREMY MAGGS: She has spent a lifetime confronting injustice, from the brutality of apartheid to the horrors of genocide and war crimes. Judge Navi Pillay has served as a judge at the International Criminal Court (ICC), as United Nations (UN) High Commissioner for Human Rights, and as a leading voice for accountability across the world. Now recognised with the Nobel Peace Prize, she joins us at a time when international law is under extraordinary pressure and the world’s most powerful nations increasingly appear willing to ignore it. Read: South African human rights lawyer Navi Pillay awarded Nobel peace prize Navi Pillay’s Nobel peace prize is a vote of confidence in a global legal order under fire Judge Pillay, thank you very much. Let me start with this, you’ve devoted your entire professional life to fighting injustice. Does the Nobel Peace Prize feel like a victory to you, or just a reminder, perhaps, of how much remains undone? NAVI PILLAY: Well, Jeremy, obviously, I didn’t apply for the award. I didn’t realise they were even considering me. I met with the selection board members in The Hague two days ago, and they appeared to have been researching me from January – a whole year – and I didn’t know. So firstly, I do celebrate this award. But secondly, you are quite right: it’s a reminder of unfinished work and as old as I am, I’ve been saying I’m not going to stop doing human rights work as long as the violations continue. It is a particularly troubling moment for human rights, but especially for the rule of law, for multilateralism, where states get together and make decisions in the organs that have the power, the Security Council, the General Assembly on, for instance, whether to attack another country. All that’s a threat, but from my point of view, it’s a threat to international justice. That troubles me most as the threatened sanctions against the ICC and thereafter that the Trump administration followed through. Where in the world would you have a government sanctioning or taking action against judges for the orders they deliver? So it’s very alarming, and it’s a deeply emotional matter. If I may continue, Jeremy, the first thing I did when I left Nuremberg and got to The Hague was to go to that court. I was invited by the president to come join them at their full staff meeting. If you see that, how much that visit alone meant to the staff and how much their emotions and fears of the threat hanging over them was conveyed to me just on their faces. I went there to show solidarity, to deliver hope that the international community, the entire population of the world, ordinary people, they want justice and accountability. We will never let the ICC be destroyed. JEREMY MAGGS: You talk about never giving up hope and have just outlined how you’ve helped build the international system of justice. How worried are you at this point, at this juncture? The very system that you’ve devoted your life to is now starting to unravel, it would seem. NAVI PILLAY: Yes, yes, I and many, many others are worried because the threats are real, and [those making them] can deliver on those threats. They have remote-controlled armed drones. You can be killed in your home without even being aware that you are targeted for killing. Families are at risk, children are at risk. It’s just reckless killing of civilians. That’s unusual. Of course, we’ve always had conflicts, since World War II, there [have been] conflicts in various parts of the world, but we have never had a third world war. In fact, Europe, a few years ago, was given the Nobel Prize for Peace simply because [it had] prevented war in Europe since World War II. ADVERTISEMENT CONTINUE READING BELOW So therefore, the threat we now face is real. It’s being done by leaders in the United States, leaders in Israel, who are defying the international rule of law. JEREMY MAGGS: Is the suggestion that it’s now a fundamental breakdown of international law? NAVI PILLAY: I would still call it a threat because of what I saw at the court and the resilience that both the judges, the prosecuting team and the hundreds of staff who were there. They believe there should be no impunity for these serious crimes, and they will continue to work. Because of that resistance and resilience, combined with civil society, with people, my support comes from ordinary people all over the world. I gave a number of interviews in The Hague, even three to Japanese television [stations]. So these calls for interviews are coming from very many countries. I’m surprised that they’re all following this. They’ve explained to me that that arises from these concerns about the breakdown of the international rule of order. JEREMY MAGGS: Judge Pillay, in that respect, then, and you talk about the voices and the concerns of ordinary people. Does it still give you a degree of hope that ordinary people are bringing about the notion that things can still turn around? NAVI PILLAY: Yes, I do. Maybe because of my experience as the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights for six years and going to various countries, seeing both the highest level of government as well as people on the ground and just being informed. I concluded that it’s not a trajectory going right down to the ground, even from top to down. Some people actually said it’s the end of human rights. This was during the first term served by President Trump, and many students at American universities asked me to address them. I was told they’re all very depressed. Read/listen: Navi Pillay’s Nobel: A victory for justice, a headache for Trump I said to them, I thought it was ups and downs, that’s what happens in human rights protection, ups and downs, because people will never let go of these hard-earned mechanisms to make governments accountable. JEREMY MAGGS: Do you think international law is genuinely international at this point, or does it still apply more forcefully to weaker countries than more powerful ones? NAVI PILLAY: We don’t have a perfect system at all, Jeremy. We will have what one can call a universal permanent world court if all the states sign up to the Rome Statute, and they haven’t. Big countries, in fact, three of the veto-holding states – Russia, China and the United States – are not parties to this court. There are just 125, plus-minus, member countries that have signed up. So we still do not have a perfect system to ensure that serious violations and to ensure that atrocity crimes are not committed against civilians. I found in my experience, it’s not all the way down, this is a dead end, no, it’s ups and downs. And why? It’s because of the effort of all the human rights defenders, ordinary people speaking out about it, writing about it. There are huge protests in streets all over for the government to deliver on their promises. JEREMY MAGGS: Do you think, Judge Pillay, it’s become more difficult to persuade ordinary people, though, to believe in a system that too many will appear to have obvious double standards? NAVI PILLAY: There’s all that. Crime still continues, [and] there are double standards. For instance, I mentioned these three powerful states. They can use the veto to protect themselves from investigation or prosecution. But let’s remind ourselves, the ICC doesn’t exercise supervening jurisdiction over national jurisdictions. So there is misinformation being spread, particularly from the US and Israel, that this is what’s happening. ADVERTISEMENT: CONTINUE READING BELOW Whereas the statute is clear, the United States could now, even now, investigate and prosecute soldiers who may have violated the laws of war and crime and committed crimes such as crimes against humanity. They have, in the past, been the one country that did prosecute its own soldiers. So if they start an investigation or prosecute, the ICC will not step in. Similarly, with every country: if you prosecute and you investigate it. So really the ICC is there to help, to be an incentive to help states. I have often said that, under apartheid, we were governed by an immoral law, which was not compatible with the Universal Charter of Human Rights that the UN adopted, and which our own apartheid government supported at the UN. Yet we had no access to justice in an independent international forum, and I always felt that loss. I wished there was a better moral system than ours. But now, Jeremy, I am citing the end of apartheid as one of my grounds for hope that that there was collective action by civil society and governments all over the world, plus a change of mind from the US and the UK to support the sanctions imposed by the UN against apartheid South Africa. So that’s an example of how collective action succeeded. Therefore, we cannot lose hope. We cannot give way to pressure. We have to continue to strategise and to struggle. But it has to be without violence. We cannot condone violent protests either. JEREMY MAGGS: Judge Pillay, your award has not been without its very vocal detractors. The UN commission concluded that Israel has committed genocide in Gaza. What do you say to those who dispute that finding and question the impartiality of your investigation? NAVI PILLAY: Firstly, they have accused me and the other two commissioners – one from India and one from Australia, with the wonderful team doing all the groundwork – they have accused us of bias and of lying. The thing is, they didn’t let us into the country, but we got most of our information from inside Israel. There’s huge support there from ordinary people. We held oral hearings in Geneva. We heard from doctors and journalists. It took us two years to prepare that report. There is not a single fact that we put out there that was not personally verified by us, together with the entire machinery of the UN, that helped us with satellite footage and so on. It’s a very comprehensive work. As I said, it took us two years to prepare, and I say to our detractors that this report is written very closely to what a court judgment would look like. So we invite anybody, since the report is public, read the facts as we’ve set it out. Look at the law. Look at the statements that we set out of the utterances of leaders whom we name as responsible for genocide and make your own decision. That way, you can resist this false propaganda [that] is trying to discredit a report that will soon be considered by the highest court in the world, the ICC. JEREMY MAGGS: Judge Pillay, when governments reject those findings that you put out. What practical consequences, then, do you think should follow? NAVI PILLAY: I think there should be stronger action by other states. There should be a clear statement by other states that they support this report. Right now, there should be a clear statement from all states condemning this action taken against the ICC. All states that support the ICC, and there are 125, I think now, should strongly express their opposition and take action to ensure that the destruction of the court does not happen. So more collective action from governments and they will find the people on the streets are very ready to support them in stronger action against one or two countries trying to destroy the multilateral system, trying to destroy the international rule of law. ADVERTISEMENT: CONTINUE READING BELOW JEREMY MAGGS: What would you say directly to political leaders, Judge Pillay, who believe they are above international law? NAVI PILLAY: I would say: you passed these laws. You passed the Rome Statute. You passed the Convention Against Torture, very many treaties, the conventions on civil and political rights for everyone in the world, and the Convention on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights. Who passed these international laws? It was states. Civil society may have made demands and followed up and did lots of the drafting, but it was the decision of governments. So why don’t they deliver on the obligations that they had undertaken under these various laws? So that would be my strongest criticism. As High Commissioner, we zeroed in just on matters of concern and offered assistance and help to do that. I visited 79 countries, so it was, a great deal of work, but an objective assessment of the same problems in every country where governments fail to deliver on the demands of the people. JEREMY MAGGS: As you told me earlier, you lived through apartheid and helped shape international justice. I wonder when you look at our country today, are you proud of what you’ve become, of what we’ve become, or disappointed perhaps by the opportunities that we’ve squandered? NAVI PILLAY: I agree that we have had many opportunities. They’re not just opportunities, they are legal provisions, a wonderful Constitution that the whole world respects. But there has been no delivery on the ground and great unhappiness. We truly are deeply concerned when a major part of the population is poverty-stricken and unemployed. So great disappointment. It can be done because we do have the institutions in place. We just need proper people to ensure that they carry out their jobs properly. This is why, Jeremy, I first was surprised that I got the award because I thought I was just doing my job as the people expect me to. We need more of that, people taking responsibility for their jobs. Corruption has reached huge levels, we’re all highly disturbed about that. But I firmly believe all that can be turned around because we have what the UN calls tools to make the change, to make the transformation happen. So very good structures, very poor delivery. I can understand why we South Africans are unhappy and why we are constantly in the news for terrible crimes, especially sexual crimes against women. JEREMY MAGGS: Navi Pillay, let me ask you one final question, because I do appreciate the time you’ve given us. After everything you’ve witnessed, the cruelty, the suffering, the extraordinary courage of victims at times – have you ever come close to losing faith in humanity? NAVI PILLAY: I’m human, Jeremy, so you do have huge disappointment, your heart sinking. For instance, I still think what have I achieved as High Commissioner when the reality on the ground is that the world is so clearly divided between the very rich and powerful and the poor, and so I live troubled by that situation, the larger picture in the world. I intend to continue. I do believe Africa has suffered as a result of colonisation, and there has to be discussions on reparations, for instance. So we have much to be concerned about, but not just to sink in despair, but to take action wherever we can. This award is truly significant because they awarded it for justice and accountability. That’s how I see it. JEREMY MAGGS: Judge Navi Pillay, thank you very much for talking to me today. Google See more of Moneyweb Google News Follow our coverage Newsletters Get news in your inbox Social Media Join the conversation Social media Follow us on our official channels: TAGS: Donald Trump | El Nino | food prices | Gaza | human rights | International Criminal Court | Jeremy Maggs | Navi Pillay | Nobel peace prize | un | United Nations AUTHOR PROFILE Jeremy Maggs Follow More articles Jeremy is a media specialist with a career spanning 40 years in television, radio, and print. He is also the host of Moneyweb’s weekly FixSA podcast. COMMENTS 0 You must be signed in to comment. SIGN IN SUBSCRIBE or create a free account. Free users can leave 4 comments per month. Subscribers can leave unlimited comments via our website and app. MORE Moneyweb@Midday Vehicle repossession: What banks can and cannot legally do 23 Oct 2026 / Jeremy Maggs Who gets the vaccines? Global pandemic deal under pressure 23 Oct 2026 / Jeremy Maggs Local bus manufacturing could add billions to SA’s economy 22 Oct 2026 / Jeremy Maggs Four months in: Is SA’s new lottery operator delivering? 22 Oct 2026 / Jeremy Maggs Medicine price hike imposed without proper consultation, industry warns 21 Oct 2026 / Jeremy Maggs Who’s delivering water and who isn’t? SA’s 144 authorities mapped 21 Oct 2026 / Jeremy Maggs LATEST INDICATORS USD / ZARGBP / ZAREUR / ZARBTC / USDJSE ALSIGOLDBrent Crude $ More Indicators ADVISOR VIEWS You sold everything – now what? 26 Oct 2026 / Wouter Fourie A living annuity is a strategy, not simply a product 26 Oct 2026 / Devon Card Tax efficient transfer of family wealth: How R300 000 a year can save a South African family millions 26 Oct 2026 / Ruan Breed What is a realistic retirement withdrawal rate, and what do advice fees cost? 23 Oct 2026 / Werner Gerber How many South Africans really have R16.5m or more? 23 Oct 2026 / Hardi Swart Go to Click an Advisor Editor's Picks Commented Top Read 1Sars hands more than 100 cases linked to commissions of inquiry to the NPA2Discovery Bank CEO out-earns Group CEO for fourth year running3SAA receives R1bn guarantee, further bailouts not ruled out 1Discovery Bank CEO out-earns Group CEO for fourth year running 122SAA staggers salary payments as cash crunch deepens 113Trumpflation and other frustrations 9 1 Sars hands more than 100 cases linked to commissions of inquiry to the NPA 2 Discovery Bank CEO out-earns Group CEO for fourth year running 3 What banking in Africa will look like in five years ADVISOR VIEWS You sold everything – now what? 26 Oct 2026 / Wouter Fourie A living annuity is a strategy, not simply a product 26 Oct 2026 / Devon Card Tax efficient transfer of family wealth: How R300 000 a year can save a South African family millions 26 Oct 2026 / Ruan Breed What is a realistic retirement withdrawal rate, and what do advice fees cost? 23 Oct 2026 / Werner Gerber Go to Click an Advisor Moneyweb Newsletters * indicates required Email Address * First Name * Last Name Moneyweb newsletters Moneyweb NOW - Morning news Moneyweb Weekly Wrap-up Op RSG Geldsake vanaand (in Afr) On SAFM Market update tonight Moneyweb Events and Webinars Moneyweb Crypto By subscribing, you agree to receive the Moneyweb emails you selected above. You can unsubscribe at any time. View our privacy policy. MORE Moneyweb@Midday Vehicle repossession: What banks can and cannot legally do 23 Oct 2026 / Jeremy Maggs Who gets the vaccines? Global pandemic deal under pressure 23 Oct 2026 / Jeremy Maggs Local bus manufacturing could add billions to SA’s economy 22 Oct 2026 / Jeremy Maggs Four months in: Is SA’s new lottery operator delivering? 22 Oct 2026 / Jeremy Maggs Medicine price hike imposed without proper consultation, industry warns 21 Oct 2026 / Jeremy Maggs Who’s delivering water and who isn’t? SA’s 144 authorities mapped 21 Oct 2026 / Jeremy Maggs LATEST ARTICLES SANBS stocks fall below target ahead of festive season 26 Oct 2026 / Phenyo Selinda The blood service needs 3 500 units daily to meet patient demand. R3bn mixed-use development breaks ground in Harrismith Government fuel intervention spares motorists more pain LATEST OPINION Off the Radar Does SA have too many malls? Trumpflation and other frustrations Sars cracks down on Vat refund fraud SPONSORED Brought to you by Ninety One Infrastructure fund delivers a return of more than 10% over 12 months 23 October 2026 Schalk Louw PSG Wealth Old Oak ASK AN ADVISOR Is my TFSA and RA portfolio positioned correctly for long-term growth? 20 October 2026 Home Latest articles Fast News In depth Absa Retail and Business Banking Bonitas Eduvos Future Forex GIBS LookSee Merchant West Nedbank Agri Nedbank CIB Ninety One OUTsurance Peregrine Capital Platinum Portfolios PSG Wealth Standard Bank Group Stanlib Investing Commodities Equities ESG ETFs Offshore investing Property SME Unit Trusts News South Africa Africa International Budget Companies and Deals Economy Fast News Investigations Industry Markets Marketingweb Mineweb Tech Radio – Listen Live SAFM Market Update RSG Geldsake Podcasts Be a Better Investor The Ballot Sheet The Business of Africa Crypto podcasts Doen jou eie ding How to Make Money Moneyweb@Midday MoneywebNOW Mzansi Business The Property Pod Special Report MyMoney Financial Planning Personal Finance Tax Opinion Columnists Soapbox Tools and data 52-Week Highs/Lows Annual Reports Asset Managers Business Calendar Company Stats Company contact info Comparison Tool Click a Company Consensus forecasts Daily Indicators Directors’ Dealings Dividend History ETFs & ETNs Heatmap JSE Sectors Portfolios/Watchlist Sens Top 40 Companies Top by Value & volume Unit Trust Holdings Unit Trust Stats Unit Trust Search Winners & Losers Moneyweb Crypto Crypto podcasts Bitcoin Ethereum MoneywebTV Executive Exchange Webinars All videos Click an Advisor Advisor Profiles Advisor Views Reader questions Submit a question Sign up – Click an Advisor Enquire – Click an Advisor Subscribe Insider GOLD Insider PRO – Click an Advisor Newsletters Support journalism Moneyweb App Stay updated Login Register Information & FAQ Help About us Contact us Advertise Authors & Presenters Careers Investor relations PAIA Manual Terms of Use (Privacy Policy, Ts & Cs) Cookie Policy Complaints Home News Newsletters Insider subscription Daily indicators Click a company Click an Advisor Radio / Livestream Podcasts About Moneyweb Advertise with us Contact Moneyweb Help Information & FAQ Moneyweb App Privacy Policy / Terms of Use Price and trade data source: JSE Ltd. Statistics calculated by Profile Data. Data is delayed by at least 15 minutes. By using this site you agree to the Terms of Use. Copyright © 2026 Moneyweb (Pty) Ltd. All Rights Reserved. ',"none"!==article_obj.is_sponsor&&(output+=''+article_obj.is_sponsor+""),output+=''+anchorTag,output+='',output+=''+article_obj.date+"",output+="",output+=""}function movePanel(id){jQuery("#"+id+"-mobile").html(jQuery("#"+id).html())}function hideMobilePanel(id){jQuery("#"+id).css("display","block"),jQuery("#"+id+"-mobile").css("display","none")}function showMobilePanel(id){jQuery("#"+id).css("display","none"),jQuery("#"+id+"-mobile").css("display","block")}function completedWindowResizing(){var width=jQuery(window).width();width Home News Latest News Fast News South Africa Africa AI Budget Companies and Deals Covid-19 Economy Eskom Industry International Investigations Markets Marketingweb Mineweb Tech In depth Absa Retail and Business Banking Bonitas Eduvos Future Forex GIBS LookSee Merchant West Nedbank Agri Nedbank CIB Ninety One Old Mutual Group Communications Otto1890 OUTsurance Peregrine Capital Platinum Portfolios PSG Wealth Standard Bank Group Stanlib Webinars Events View all MyMoney Educational Video Series Financial Planning Personal Finance Retirement #SavingsMonth Tax Investing Commodities Equities ESG ETFs Offshore investing Property SME Unit Trusts Crypto Crypto news Crypto podcasts Bitcoin Ethereum Opinion Columnists Soapbox Desk of the President Podcasts All podcasts Be a Better Investor The Ballot Sheet with Ray Mahlaka The Business of Africa Crypto podcasts Executive Exchange FixSA How to Make Money With … Mandates & Megaphones Moneyweb@Midday MoneywebNOW Mzansi Business The Property Pod Supernatural Stocks Special Report Doen jou eie ding Small Business Conversations Radio Listen live RSG Geldsake SAFM Market Update MoneywebTV Executive Exchange Mzansi Business Click an Advisor Sign up for Click an Advisor All advisor profiles Advisor views Reader questions Submit your question Contact us Tools and data All data tools 52-week highs/lows Asset Managers Annual Reports Business calendar Click a Company Company contacts Company stats Comparison Tool Daily indicators Directors’ dealings Dividend History ETF & ETN search Heatmap JSE sectors Portfolio Tool / Watchlist SENS Top 40 Companies Top by value/volume Unit Trust holdings Unit Trust Search Unit Trust Stats Winners and losers INSIDER SUBSCRIPTION APP NEWSLETTERS PODCASTS RADIO / LISTEN LIVE VIDEOS WEBINARS TRENDING FOLLOW US: SEARCH: Search Search JSE companies: Unit Trusts ETFs/ETNs SENS TRENDING: More Sars cracks down on Vat refund fraud 25 Oct 2026 / Richan Schwellnus 2 Learners wait seven years for R39m school 25 Oct 2026 / Nombulelo Damba-Hendrik, GroundUp IN DEPTH: Sponsored Brought to you by Eris Property Group Own in Newlands with a 10% rental guarantee and 100% finance at The Marlow Brought to you by Ninety One Infrastructure fund delivers a return of more than 10% over 12 months SIGN IN: Email Password Stay logged in Forgot password Create a free account, or contact us to assist. Access all our articles Post comments and replies News & Sens email alerts Premium data tools Sens archive and Sens PDFs. SUBSCRIBE NOW You can cancel at any time.Read the full article at Moneyweb
Article details
- Published
- October 26, 2026
- Last updated
- November 12, 2026
- Written by
- ADM Staff
- Category
- Business and Finance
- Reading time
- 22 min read
- Views
- 2